Playoffs
| Year | Playoff | Round | W/L | Score | Opponent | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1972 | Class A State | Semifinal | L | 0-18 | Lorain Clearview Clippers | Upper Arlington HS |
| 1973 | Class A State | Semifinal | W | 16-0 | Ashtabula St.John Fighting Heralds | Upper Arlington HS |
| Class A State | Final | W | 27-7 | Montpelier Locomotives | Ohio Wesleyan University | |
| 1974 | Class A State | Semifinal | W | 34-6 | Newark Catholic Green Waves | Lancaster HS |
| Class A State | Final | W | 21-0 | Fremont St.Joseph Crimson Streaks | Upper Arlington HS | |
| 1975 | Class A State | Semifinal | L | 0-11 | Newark Catholic Green Waves | Groveport-Madison HS |
| 1978 | Class A State | Semifinal | L | 6-20 | Newark Catholic Green Waves | Groveport-Madison HS |
| 1982 | Div. V Regional | Final | L | 6-14 | Bradford Railroaders | Troy HS |
| 1983 | Div. V Regional | Final | W | 26-21 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Barnitz Stadium, Middletown |
| Div. V State | Semifinal | L | 0-7 | McComb Panthers | Troy HS | |
| 1984 | Div. V Regional | Final | W | 34-0 | Lehman Catholic Cavaliers | Barnitz Stadium, Middletown |
| Div. V State | Semifinal | W | 22-21 | Holgate Tigers | Troy HS | |
| Div. V State | Final | L | 6-14 | Newark Catholic Green Waves | Ohio State University | |
| 1985 | Div. V Regional | Semifinal | W | 16-10 | Cincinnati Summit Country Day Silver Knights | Barnitz Stadium, Middletown |
| Div. V Regional | Final | L | 0-3 | Covington Buccaneers | Welcome Stadium, Dayton | |
| 1987 | Div. V Regional | Semifinal | W | 3-0 | Minster Wildcats | Troy HS |
| Div. V Regional | Final | W | 10-0 | St.Henry Redskins | Clayton Northmont HS | |
| Div. V State | Semifinal | L | 0-21 | Newark Catholic Green Waves | Ohio State University | |
| 1988 | Div. V Regional | Semifinal | W | 21-13 | Cedarville Indians | Monroe HS |
| Div. V Regional | Final | L | 6-17 | Minster Wildcats | Troy HS | |
| 1991 | Div. V Regional | Semifinal | W | 21-13 | Marion Pleasant Spartans | Evans Stadium, Springfield |
| Div. V Regional | Final | L | 3-7 | Cincinnati Country Day Indians | Lockland HS | |
| 2003 | Div. V Regional | Quarterfinal | L | 20-49 | Marion Pleasant Spartans | Marion Pleasant HS |
| 2004 | Div. V Regional | Quarterfinal | L | 13-19 | West Liberty Salem Tigers | West Liberty Salem HS |
| 2012 | Div. IV Regional | Quarterfinal | L | 14-21 | Norwood Indians | Norwood HS |
| 2015 | Div. IV Regional | Quarterfinal | W | 14-7 | Hamilton Badin Rams | Fenwick HS |
| Div. IV Regional | Semifinal | W | 19-9 | Alter Knights | West Carrollton HS | |
| Div. IV Regional | Final | W | 10-3 | Clarksville Clinton-Massie Falcons | Xenia HS | |
| Div. IV State | Semifinal | L | 14-26 | Columbus Bishop Hartley Hawks | Wilmington HS | |
| 2018 | Div. III Regional | Quarterfinal | W | 28-7 | Chaminade-Julienne Eagles | Fenwick HS |
| Div. III Regional | Semifinal | L | 17-27 | Wapakoneta Redskins | Piqua HS | |
| 2020 | Div. IV Regional | 1st Round | L | 7-40 | Cincinnati Mount Healthy Fighting Owls | Mount Healthy HS |
| 16-16 | ||||||