| 2021 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Associated Press | Playoff | |
| Division | Team | Team |
| I | Powell Olentangy Liberty | Rocky River Magnificat |
| II | Gates Mills Gilmour Academy | Gates Mills Gilmour Academy |
| III | Independence | Findlay Liberty-Benton |
| IV | New Bremen | New Knoxville |
| 2022 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Associated Press | Playoff | |
| Division | Team | Team |
| I | Cincinnati Ursuline Academy | Cincinnati Ursuline Academy |
| II | Columbus Bishop Hartley | Chardon Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin |
| III | Mentor Lake Catholic | Mentor Lake Catholic |
| IV | New Bremen | New Bremen |
| 2023 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Associated Press | Playoff | |
| Division | Team | Team |
| I | Cincinnati Seton | Kings |
| II | Mercy McAuley | Mercy McAuley |
| III | Mentor Lake Catholic | Mentor Lake Catholic |
| IV | New Bremen | |